Lawyer bots take the hassle out of fighting parking tickets and property taxes — and could cost local governments real revenue

How Complete Beginners are using an ‘Untapped’ Google Network to create Passive Income ON DEMAND

A new pain for cities.

After finding a parking ticket lashed to his windshield, Seattle resident Dan Lear normally would have bitten the bullet and paid up, even though he felt misled by street signage.

Instead, Lear decided to try his luck with DoNotPay, a free bot service that streamlines the process of contesting parking tickets. The service helped Lear win a dismissal in 2016, leaving him a little bit richer and Seattle a little bit poorer.

New technology-powered services like DoNotPay, WinIt and TurboAppeal are encouraging more people to challenge legal hassles like inaccurate tickets and property taxes online. While these tools can help citizens avoid unfair penalties, they also might tempt some users to game the system, and could strain the resources of local governments. These potential side effects might come at an inopportune time for municipalities, whose budgets may be squeezed under the new tax rules.

“I guess I’m torn between supporting my local government but also ensuring that people have the right to appeal things that they feel are not fair or not legal,” said the victorious Lear, who is an attorney by trade.

DoNotPay asks users a series of questions, such as whether a parking sign was difficult to read or a ticket had incorrect details, then produces a letter with a formal legal defense that drivers can mail in or submit online.

The free service has helped drivers across the U.S. and the U.K. squash more than 450,000 parking tickets representing $ 13 million in fines; users win dismissals more than 50 percent of the time, by founder Joshua Browder’s estimate. That compares to a dismissal rate of around 35 percent in Los Angeles and 21 percent in New York City.

Parking tickets are “used as a source of revenue, which is wrong, and something I’m trying to change for the longer term,” said Browder, who has been called the “Robin Hood of the internet” by the BBC. Local governments, he added, “generally don’t like me.”

Having recently clinched $ 1.1 million in seed funding, DoNotPay lists investors including Andreessen Horowitz, Greylock Partners and attorneys with the firm Wilson Sonsini. The company plans to expand into helping users fight property taxes and file for divorce, among other things.

WinIt, a mobile app that currently only services New York City but plans to expand this year, takes parking ticket challenges to the next level. It builds a legal defense with minimal or zero input, and then argues for a dismissal, often in court through a partner attorney, and proceeds “even if there’s a 5 percent chance that we can dismiss the ticket,” said WinIt CEO Ouriel Lemmel.

WinIt collects a fee — equal to half the fine — but only if it succeeds. Drivers can even sign up for WinIt’s “Ticket Guardian,” which will automatically challenge any new ticket associated with a customer’s license plate number as soon as it hits a government database.

Companies that depend on drivers are taking note: Ride-sharing app Via and delivery service Postmates both offer discounts on WinIt to their drivers.

WinIt expects to contest 3 percent to 4 percent of all New York City parking tickets this year, which could amount to well over 300,000 tickets, if 2018 ticket volume is similar to previous years. That could represent around $ 6 million in potential lost revenue for the city.

Appealing property taxes

At least one startup is also taking aim at a much larger source of municipal revenue: Property taxes.

Machine-learning-powered TurboAppeal makes it much easier for homeowners to challenge the property assessments used to levy property taxes. The company had raised more than $ 7 million from investors including online mortgage lender Guaranteed Rate, KGC Capital, Hyde Park Venture Partners and real estate brokerage @properties before being acquired by Paradigm Tax Group for an undisclosed sum last year.

Homeowners can get detailed data and instructions that can cut the time needed to prepare a compelling appeal from hours to 30 minutes, according to Stace Hunt, marketing director at Paradigm. Priced at $ 49, the automated service typically costs much less than a property tax attorney.

Amanda McMillan, a Chicago realtor who used TurboAppeal to shave $ 700 off her 2015 tax bill, said a few clients who probably would not have otherwise fought their property taxes followed her advice and gave TurboAppeal a whirl. To their delight, they won reductions, she said.

TurboAppeal had reportedly generated more than 100,000 property tax appeals as of May 2017; it covers 64 counties and 23 million single-family homes and has claimed a success rate of more than 75 percent in the past.

Some data suggests that self-service companies like TurboAppeal and DoNotPay have lots of room to grow.

The opportunity

Public New York City data, along with statistics provided to Recode by the Los Angeles Department of Transportation, showed that fewer than 10 percent of parking tickets were challenged in those two cities over the last few years, while less than 5 percent of properties in all but one of New Jersey’s 21 counties saw their tax bills appealed in 2016.

But more fine dismissals and property tax reductions would mean less money for local schools and police departments, noted Megan Randall, a research associate at the Urban Institute. Property taxes reportedly make up roughly 30 percent of local government revenue nationwide.

Illustrating how services that target this revenue could pose a fiscal nuisance, New Jersey’s Monroe County was forced to issue a bond in 2011 to cover $ 5 million in refunds due to a spike in property tax appeals. The increase was driven by the housing meltdown, though the town’s finance director at the time also cited attorneys “trying to convince residents to file mass appeals,” the Star-Ledger reported.

Parking tickets, meanwhile, account for less than 1 percent of local government revenue nationwide, but some municipalities are much more reliant on fines than others.

For example, in 2013, 21 of the 90 municipalities in Missouri’s St. Louis County collected more than 20 percent of revenue from court fines and fees, of which parking and speeding tickets are a large contributor.

Drops in traffic tickets can cut into state budgets, too. A decrease in ticket volume forced the Nevada Supreme Court to seek a bailout in 2015. DoNotPay and WinIt can help users fight moving violations such as speeding tickets, so they could also nibble away at revenue from a range of traffic fines, not just parking tickets.

A jump in appeals would also increase the workload of municipal employees who are tasked with reviewing ticket and tax challenges.

“At this point, we don’t have an automated process, so it may cost our constituents money,” said Mark Granado, manager of parking operations and support for the LA Department of Transportation.

Moreover, many people may use these services to try to game the system, not to right a wrong.

WinIt and DoNotPay can help users get off on technicalities, such as if a ticket incorrectly describes a car’s color or make. Such errors can cost big bucks: New York City recently announced that it would refund a reported $ 26 million worth of parking tickets due to the omission of a zero from the ordinance code on roughly 500,000 tickets.

The government finance, parking enforcement and county appraiser employees that Recode spoke to said they didn’t believe that services such as WinIt, DoNotPay or TurboAppeal have boosted ticket and tax challenges so far, but generally acknowledged the potential for this to occur.

Some, including Granado, the Los Angeles parking enforcement official, said they would welcome services that professionalize more appeals, while a few employees encouraged consumers to consider using government systems, questioning whether third-party services add value.

Asked about concerns with their services, WinIt, DoNotPay and TurboAppeal emphasized that they are simply empowering more consumers to exercise their legal rights.

Municipalities could try to deal with more appeal volume by increasing property tax rates and fines or by investing in technology. But this could be harder than ever, given that the recent tax reform may impose downward pressure on property taxes, among other budget constraints.

“In an ideal world, governments would invest in the necessary resources to adapt,” Randall said in an email. “However, in reality, we often become reliant on private-sector actors who derive material benefit from a complex and opaque tax system.”

Teke Wiggin is a Brooklyn-based reporter who covers technology, labor and housing. Reach him @tkwiggin.

Recode – All

Cash For Apps: Make money with android app

Uber’s lawyer says the ex-employee who made allegations about security practices was trying to extort the company

However, Uber went on to pay the employee, Richard Jacobs, to be a consultant.

Continue reading…

The Verge – All Posts

Recode Daily: Trump picks a big company lawyer to head the agency that watches big companies

Plus: Russian agents used Facebook’s Messenger to muddy the waters, the first hard numbers on Silicon Valley diversity statistics, and Lego launches “Women of NASA.”

U.S. President Donald Trump wants to nominate antitrust lawyer Joe Simons as the next chairman of the Federal Trade Commission. Simons has previously represented big tech companies including Microsoft. Trump’s pick means that he’s unlikley to back up previous promises to break up big companies, particularly in media and telecom. [Tony Romm / Recode]

Misinformation campaigns have been top of mind in Silicon Valley since last year’s U.S. presidential election. Just yesterday, a top Facebook exec admitted that Russian agents had used the company’s popular Messenger platform. But a new study of tech experts found that more than 50 percent don’t believe the “information environment” has a chance of improving. And the more hopeful experts put their hopes in … technology. [Kurt Wagner / Recode]

Blue Apron is laying off 6 percent of its staff — more than 300 employees. The meal-delivery startup has had a rough go as a public company since its June IPO. [Jason Del Rey / Recode]

The Los Angeles Police Department will be the largest U.S. police force to rely on drones. As part of a year-long pilot program, drone flights will be restricted to SWAT team members in dangerous situations, such as when a heavily armed suspect is on the loose, and for search-and-rescue missions. Each flight must be approved, documented and reviewed, and there’s a ban on facial-recognition software. [Jon Fingas / Engadget]


Recode presents …

AT&T veteran John Stankey will be the boss of one of the biggest media companies in the world, once AT&T completes its $ 86 billion deal to acquire Time Warner. Effectively replacing outgoing Time Warner CEO Jeff Bewkes, Stankey will oversee HBO, Warner Bros., CNN, TNT and more. What’s his plan? We’ll ask him at Code Media next February in Huntington Beach, California. Register now and save $ 500 with the First Mover Price.


Top stories from Recode

Amazon’s invasion of Kohl’s has begun.

An unlikely tie-up begins.

Square and Pinterest’s newly released employment data reveals a lack of diversity in top ranks

Have a look at the top brass.

An Abu Dhabi sovereign fund is doubling down on tech with more cash, more office space and more SoftBank.

Mubadala is here to stay.

TV producers can now see how many people are watching Netflix shows.

Netflix viewership is no longer a black box.

Former Chartbeat CEO Tony Haile wants to save the media industry — by blocking ads.

His new startup, Scroll, will charge consumers once for an ad-free experience across many news sites on all platforms.

AI can take over our mundane tasks. Here’s how human workers can learn new, more stimulating skills.

The “coaching cloud” will create the first Facebook-scale enterprise business.

This is cool

Lego is launching a “Women of NASA” set.


Recode – All

Trump is nominating a longtime antitrust lawyer as the head of the Federal Trade Commission

Joe Simons has represented companies like Microsoft, and may be the country’s privacy, competition and consumer protection cop.

President Donald Trump intends to nominate Joe Simons, a longtime antitrust lawyer who has represented tech companies like Microsoft, as the next chairman of the Federal Trade Commission, a White House official confirmed on Wednesday.

Trump also plans to announce his candidate to fill the open Democratic slot at the FTC: Rohit Chopra, an ally of Sen. Elizabeth Warren.

Both nominees must still win confirmation by the U.S. Senate, where federal lawmakers — particularly Democrats — have expressed fresh fears about the power and reach of the tech industry.

The FTC has a hand in reviewing major mergers, scrutinizing companies’ business practices, protecting online privacy and data security and otherwise policing the corporate world for unfair and deceptive acts or practices. Under its current acting chairman — Maureen Ohlhausen, a Republican, whom Trump has bypassed for the permanent gig — the agency recently has penalized Uber for misusing its customers’ data and blocked a merger of FanDuel and DraftKings, two daily fantasy sports sites.

To that end, Simons and Chopra may face a tough grilling from those in Congress would like to see the watchdog agency set its sights on tech giants like Amazon, Facebook, Google and others.

Simons, for his part, served at the FTC as the leader of its Bureau of Competition from 2001 to 2003. He is currently a partner at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, where he has previously represented Rockstar — a coalition of Microsoft, Ericsson, RIM and Sony that sought to purchase patents from Nortel Networks for $ 4.5 billion. He has also aided companies including Sharp Corporation and MasterCard.

In Simons, Trump has telegraphed once again that his rhetoric — promising to break up big companies, particularly in media and telecom — is unlikely to shape his government’s own antitrust policy.

And Chopra, a Democrat, is a senior fellow at the Consumer Federation of America. Before arriving at the watchdog group, he served as an assistant director at the U.S. government’s Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, where he focused on student lending. Warren and Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer had recommended Chopra to Trump for the post. (Typically, lawmakers in the minority party are granted great deference in submitting candidates for their slots on commissions like the FTC.)

Chopra, if confirmed, would join Commissioner Terrell McSweeny as the FTC’s two Democratic members. McSweeny, however, could leave the commission in the coming months, so Trump may soon face another vacancy to fill at the agency.

Not on the list: Sean Reyes, the Utah attorney general who at one point had been seen as a candidate to lead the FTC. In the months after his name first surfaced, he appeared to fall out of favor at the White House. That amounts to a win for Google, given the fact Reyes previously had advocated for an antitrust probe of the search giant.

And sources still expect Trump to tap Noah Phillips, a congressional aide, as a Republican commissioner to round out the five-member agency. Phillips is currently the chief counsel to Sen. John Cornyn on the chamber’s Judiciary Committee, where he advises his Republican boss on antitrust and privacy. He also has spent time in private practice, focused on civil litigation at firms like Cravath, Swaine & Moore.


Recode – All

Jared Kushner’s lawyer can’t stop owning himself

Jared Kushner’s lawyer accidentally forwarded an email to a fake Jared Kushner email account today, one that included a letter marked as “committee sensitive” from the Senate Intelligence Committee. The letter, signed by committee chair Richard Burr (R-NC) and vice chair Mark Warner (D-VA), expresses concern about media reports regarding Kushner’s use of a personal email account.

This is the second time that Abbe Lowell, a partner at Norton Rose Fulbright LLP, who began representing Kushner in June, has fallen for a prankster who calls himself SINON_REBORN (a reference to the original legend of the Trojan Horse). Two days ago he corresponded with kushner.jared@mail.com, as the fake Jared Kushner asked for legal advice on whether to…

Continue reading…

The Verge – All Posts

Chatbot lets you sue Equifax for up to $25,000 without a lawyer

Equifax’s security failure affected 143 million US consumers, or 44 percent of the US population. To add insult to injury, Equifax waited over a month before revealing the security breach it had suffered. If you’re one of the millions affected by the breach, a chatbot can now help you sue Equifax in small claims court, potentially letting you avoid hiring a lawyer for advice.

Even if you want to be part of the class action lawsuit against Equifax, you can still sue Equifax for negligence in small claims court using the DoNotPay bot and demand maximum damages. Maximum damages range between $ 2,500 in states like Rhode Island and Kentucky to $ 25,000 in Tennessee.

The bot, which launched in…

Continue reading…

The Verge – All Posts

AI lawyer can help you with a thousand different legal issues

Over two years ago, Joshua Browder, now a junior at Stanford University, created a chatbot that could contest parking tickets in New York City and London. By June of 2016, DoNotPay had successfully contested 160,000 parking tickets — a 64 percent su…
Engadget RSS Feed