San Francisco curbs sidewalk-hogging delivery robots

San Francisco curbs sidewalk-hogging delivery robots

Regulations limiting the number of delivery robots permitted on sidewalks have been passed, as activists push back against the rise of delivery automation startups.

When a world-renowned centre of innovation such as San Francisco faces opposition to disruption, it’s a sharp reminder of the need for regulations to keep pace with technological advancements. Washington DC, Virginia and Idaho already have laws permitting delivery robots to operate, but San Francisco has been slower to legislate for the technology, despite Silicon Valley’s proximity.

We’ve seen this sort of regulatory scrambling in response to the emergence of Uber and Airbnb. Delivery robots are the latest targets to face the scrutiny of the law. Companies such as Marble and Starship are springing up to offer “robots as a service”, with business models that enable food retailers to contract out delivery to automated alternatives.

Read more: Hermes and Starship Technologies to test delivery robots in London

What regulation means for delivery robots

San Francisco supervisor Norman Yee, who authored the legislation, originally pursued a ban on such robots, arguing that the city’s streets “are for people, not robots”. However, this absolute approach was relaxed in October to look at regulation instead.

“Not every innovation is all that great for society,” said Yee, addressing the city’s Board of Supervisors. “If we don’t value our society, if we don’t value getting the chance to go the store without being run over by a robot… What is happening?”

“When it comes to being proactive about the development of common-sense regulations for commuter shuttles or the sharing economy, such as Airbnb or Uber, somehow we have sent the signal that it is acceptable to act now and ask for forgiveness later,” Yee said at a public hearing on the legislation in October. “That is not an example of a city that leads.”

Following the legislation, each company will be limited to three robot permits, and only nine will be available at any time for the entire city. The robots will also be restricted to certain industrial areas, 6-feet wide sidewalks and must be chaperoned at all times. On top of this, a maximum speed of 3 miles per hour will be imposed. Together, these rules will severely restrict the ambitions of the likes of Marble and Starship.

The San Francisco Chamber of Commerce lobbied against an all-out ban of such robots, saying it “could create a massive barrier to future innovation in the industry”. Other proponents argued that robots could play an important part in delivering medicines to elderly members of the community who are unable to get to a pharmacy.

Read more: Ford, Domino’s Pizza to trial self-driving delivery service in US

Guiding innovation and disruption

Nonetheless, the overcrowding of sidewalks is undeniably an issue. They simply weren’t designed to accommodate robots too, and activists stressed the risk delivery robots pose to the elderly and disabled.

“Sidewalks, I believe, are not playgrounds for the new remote-controlled toys of the clever to make money and eliminate jobs,” said Lorraine Petty, an activist with the community group Senior and Disability Action, the Guardian reports. “They’re for us to walk.”

In the long term, some cities may start building designated lanes for robots. For many though, the issue goes beyond the monopolizing of sidewalks. “Are robots necessary?” asked San Francisco resident Lori Liederman. “Maybe it isn’t just our safety that’s in jeopardy. Maybe it’s our humanity as well.”

Philosophy aside, like most automation, delivery robots have the potential to both harm and benefit society. It comes down to scale, what they’re delivering and why. Often, we’d benefit from fetching food ourselves or using a human delivery service but in other cases robot deliveries could augment existing services, or provide an affordable lifeline to isolated individuals.

This scope for benefit and harm is common to disruption and the hopes, fears and unknowns that come with it. In the face of such, there is a very real need for regulation to protect the wider interests of society, while leaving space to innovate and grow. It’s a difficult balance, that encompasses technical, social, legal and economic considerations.

Read more: launches robot delivery in China

The post San Francisco curbs sidewalk-hogging delivery robots appeared first on Internet of Business.

Internet of Business

IPhone X delivery times improve worldwide, down to 1-3 days in some markets

Article Image

Apple this weekend updated its regional online stores to reflect improvements in iPhone X availability, which is now shipping in as few as one to three days in some locations.
AppleInsider – Frontpage News

San Francisco Approves Tight Regulations on Delivery Robots

Express Delivery

Delivery robots are still a rare sight in the U.S., but that might not be the case for much longer. In order to get ahead of the game, authorities in San Francisco have passed new regulations that will control their usage.

Companies will be limited to three robots each, only nine of which will be allowed to traverse the whole city. These limits were put in place by new rules enacted by San Francisco’s board of supervisors. Furthermore, the activity of these robots will be limited to industrial areas where there aren’t many people around.

The regulations also state that the machines are not permitted to travel at more than three miles per hour, and must be accompanied by a human supervisor at all times. Bob Doyle, a spokesman for the Association for Advancing Automation Association, compared these restrictions to the early days of automotive vehicles where cars had to be preceded by a person carrying a flag.

“To put such a strict limit on these types of autonomous delivery vehicles drastically slows down the process of testing and the potential for these being put into (use before) the general public,” Doyle told the San Francisco Chronicle.

If delivery robots are ever to enter widespread use, it’s vitally important that they have been tested at length, and in similar conditions to those that they’ll ultimately be working in. It’s being argued that these restrictions are short-sighted, as they could prevent companies from perfecting these machines through that kind of rigorous, real-world testing.

The original proposal submitted by supervisor Norman Yee set out to ban the robots outright. The ban was proposed to prevent the robots from overcrowding sidewalks, similar to previously proposed bans pertaining to Segways and bicycles.

Machines Among Us

Automation and artificial intelligence give various industries new opportunities when it comes to their workforce. This will change the job market for humans, but it’s also set to have a wider impact on society.

For instance, if a delivery robot causes an accident, who is to blame? Responsibility would likely fall to the company that owns it, but there isn’t the direct culpability that would apply to an individual. Without the proper means of compelling the owners of these robots to prioritize public safety, putting limitations on their usage might be the best idea.

San Francisco is something of an outlier when it comes to its restrictions of delivery robots. Elsewhere in California, including the Bay Area, Redwood City, San Carlos, Sunnyvale, and Concord, pilot programs have been approved. While further afield, other states, including Idaho, Wisconsin, Virginia, Florida, and Ohio, have all given their blessing for robots traversing city streets, too.

Integrating robots and other automated workers into our society will offer up all kinds of moral and ethical dilemmas. This technology stands to contribute a wide range of benefits to our society, but we’ll need to carefully plan the unleashing of robots in our cities if we want to walk peacefully beside them on the sidewalk.

The post San Francisco Approves Tight Regulations on Delivery Robots appeared first on Futurism.


DoorDash offers free delivery when you use ‘Pay with Google’ on an order this month ($7 credit for new users)

If you’re a tightwad like me, you’ll probably agree when I say food delivery services are a bit of an indulgence. But when there’s a promo going on, especially during a chilly time of the year, it becomes a lot easier to justify such an extravagance. Enter DoorDash, which is offering free delivery for anyone who makes an order via its Android app and uses the “Pay with Google” payment option during the month of December.

Read More

DoorDash offers free delivery when you use ‘Pay with Google’ on an order this month ($ 7 credit for new users) was written by the awesome team at Android Police.

Android Police – Android News, Apps, Games, Phones, Tablets

Amazon envisions delivery drones that self-destruct in emergencies

It's been years now since Amazon revealed its plan to begin using drones for delivery, and the company has slowly been improving and refining the idea ever since. Now, Amazon has been granted a patent on tech that would allow its drones to self-destr…
Engadget RSS Feed